# sommelier-answered

_Witnessed 2026-09-04T14:42:21.336Z — QRATE-UAT-1_

**Re-checking my own filed finding STR-1195.** The earlier walk read the helper's empty message without answering its three questions. This one answers them.

> **Before I answer anything:** the empty message is present 1 time(s). This is the state my earlier walk read and filed a bug about.

### 01 · PATRON

**I expected:** I sit down and open THE CELLAR

**I saw:** opened. empty-element count before answering = 1. Screen: Drinks Starters Mains Desserts BEVERAGES 1 MORE 8 Beverages 1 dish C Canary Iced Tea Canary baseline beverage — DO NOT MODIFY. $3.49 THE CELLAR Find your perfec

> **I chose:** q1 -> white · q2 -> dry · q3 -> light

### 02 · PATRON

**I expected:** I answer all three questions

**I saw:** q1 -> white · q2 -> dry · q3 -> light. Screen: Drinks Starters Mains Desserts BEVERAGES 1 MORE 8 Beverages 1 dish C Canary Iced Tea Canary baseline beverage — DO NOT MODIFY. $3.49 THE CELLAR Find your perfect pour Answer 3 questions · we’ll pair t

> **Network:** 200 https://jlk5auefmk.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/recommendation/wine/facets/28ae37ab-706c-4e20-83d7-52f5d2dff747 · 200 https://jlk5auefmk.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/recommendation/wine/facets/28ae37ab-706c-4e20-83d7-52f5d2dff747 · 200 https://jlk5auefmk.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/recommendation/wine/score

> **The result panel says:** YOUR POUR TONIGHT Canary White Wine OFF-DRY Serving REQUIRED BY GLASS $10.00 BY BOTTLE $40.00 ↺ Start over Other pours ADDS TO CART Canary Red Wine DRY BY GLASS $11.00 +

### 03 · PATRON

**I expected:** The helper now recommends actual wines to me

**I saw:** empty-element count = 0. It recommends: YOUR POUR TONIGHT Canary White Wine OFF-DRY Serving REQUIRED BY GLASS $10.00 BY BOTTLE $40.00 ↺ Start over Other pours ADDS TO CART Canary Red Wine DRY BY GLASS $11.00 +

---

**Verdict:** HONEST_GREEN

**Why it ended here:** Answered, the helper recommends priced wines. The empty message my earlier walk read was the PRE-ANSWER placeholder, not an empty cellar — so STR-1195 is my error and must be retracted.